The blog for Mets fans
who like to read

ABOUT US

Jason Fry and Greg Prince
Faith and Fear in Flushing made its debut on Feb. 16, 2005, the brainchild of two longtime friends and lifelong Met fans.

Greg Prince discovered the Mets when he was 6, during the magical summer of 1969. He is a Long Island-based writer, editor and communications consultant. Contact him here.

Jason Fry is a Brooklyn writer whose first memories include his mom leaping up and down cheering for Rusty Staub. Check out his other writing here.

Got something to say? Leave a comment, or email us at faithandfear@gmail.com.

Need our RSS feed? It's here.

Visit our Facebook page, or drop by the personal pages for Greg and Jason.

Or follow us on Twitter: Here's Greg, and here's Jason.

Roberto Hernandez, the Bell Tolls for Thee

I've adopted Heath Bell as my first sentimental favorite of 2005. Part

of it's reading about him rollerblading with his daughter in the

driveway, which I thought was a sweet story. More than that, though, is

the fact that he's straight out of the Moneyball template.

One of my favorite parts of Moneyball

is the chapter on Chad Bradford, the reliever with the delivery so

strange that smug scouts dubbed him “the Creature” and ignored him

despite success on every level, until Billy Beane looked at the numbers

and grabbed him. I can only imagine Bell would also qualify for

Creaturehood from those who evaluate baseball players as if they were

selling jeans, as Moneyball puts it. Heck, as you know, I've made fun of poor Heath myself in that vein.

“What is that on the mound? Look at

that big rear and that belly. And what size are his shoes, a 4? I bet

he can't even see those tiny little feet under that big belly of his.

Wait, he's going into his motion. What is he doing? What kind of motion

is that? Is he mincing? I think ya gotta call whatever it is he's doing mincing. That body, that motion … I tell ya, it's unnatural.”

So here's a link to what was probably my favorite baseball story from last summer: Alan Schwarz's Aug. 15 New York Times article on judging relievers by inherited runs prevented — a measure thought up, as I understand it, by Baseball Prospectus.

Schwarz's overview is a great primer, and Mike Stanton is one of its

key figures. And it reveals just how sucky he'd been to that point: a

3.75 ERA, but third-worst in baseball in preventing inherited runners

from scoring.

That led me to dig up Baseball Prospectus' stats for reliever performance

in 2004. The sabermetrical waters get deep here, but the important

column is INR — inherited runners prevented. Stanton got better after

being outed in the Times, finishing with a -4.2 INR, good for only 14th

worst in baseball. Way to go, Mike. (Felix Heredia's stats with the

Yankees? -2.6. Bad, but not Stantonesque in their horror.) Rick

Peterson can lay claim to having helped Mike DeJean — DeJean's Orioles

INR was a putrid -7.9, but with the Mets he recorded a -0.2. Bartolome

Fortunato recorded a 0.5 — while the less-celebrated Orber Moreno had

a pretty decent 3.1 and the now-vanished Ricky Bottalico had a 3.5,

second-best on the team. But the best INR? 3.6. And it belonged to …

Heath Bell.

(I swear I didn't know that when I started this entry. But I'm smiling nonetheless.)

But how much do you want to bet some retread like Roberto Hernandez

(2004 INR -3.8) or Scott Stewart (-4.5) makes the team instead? We'll

be told they've thrown the ball really well and have experience.

Experience at what? Being sucky?

Heresy alert: I don't think Gil Hodges belongs in the Hall of Fame. I

know, I should be rubbed in shoe polish, set afire and wreathed in blue

and orange flames, and I've tried to change my own mind, but I don't. Here are the stats

— scroll down and look at the “similar batters.” Sure, you remember

all these guys, but are they Cooperstown material? Would we let in Gil

if we knew Tino Martinez would follow?

But he was the Gary Cooper of the Miracle Mets!

I know he was, and while I was just four months old when Cleon dropped to one knee

(Mom and Dad assure me I did see it), I grew up reading every

account of '69 I could find, until it became Holy Writ, which is as it

should be. Had Hodges lived, I firmly believe he would have entered

Cooperstown as a manager. (And our 1970s might look a whole lot better,

Seaver would never have become a Red, Koosman a Twin…no, stop, that

way lies madness.) But he didn't live. He died young, tragically young,

and so the doors are closed there too.

A Met Hall of Famer, sure — he's on the outfield wall where he

belongs, and it's right and proper that all managers who have followed

him or will do so will be measured against him. But I can't see

Cooperstown. I've tried. But I just can't.

1 comment to Roberto Hernandez, the Bell Tolls for Thee

  • Anonymous

    by that criteria tony perez doesn't belong either…yet he's in. aren't we measuring players by those already in? if so, then there are enough comparables to make the leap of faith.