The blog for Mets fans
who like to read


Greg Prince and Jason Fry
Faith and Fear in Flushing made its debut on Feb. 16, 2005, the brainchild of two longtime friends and lifelong Met fans.

Greg Prince discovered the Mets when he was 6, during the magical summer of 1969. He is a Long Island-based writer, editor and communications consultant. Contact him here.

Jason Fry is a Brooklyn writer whose first memories include his mom leaping up and down cheering for Rusty Staub. Check out his other writing here.

Got something to say? Leave a comment, or email us at (Sorry, but we have no interest in ads, sponsored content or guest posts.)

Need our RSS feed? It's here.

Visit our Facebook page, or drop by the personal pages for Greg and Jason.

Or follow us on Twitter: Here's Greg, and here's Jason.

What It Means to Be John Maine

All hail our most-reliable pitcher, the glue of the rotation, the man we turn to in times of need. All hail…John Maine?

Yep, John Maine. Who should stand as just the latest reminder that as a collective fan base, we say a lot but know a little.

Consider the many lives — in 2006 alone — of John Kevin Maine, born May 8, 1981 (your blogger's 12th birthday, by the way) outside Washington, D.C.

January-March: The “Who?” Months. Meet the other guy in the Kris Benson trade, if you remember his name. The five-second scouting report: Did well in the minors, got shelled in the bigs. If his name was spoken at all, it was as an ironic counterpoint to ranting about Jorge Julio. “…AND THE GUY CAN'T PITCH, HE'S A FREAKIN' HEAD CASE, AND HE EVEN FRIGGIN' LOOKS LIKE ARMANDO BENITEZ!” At which point the other guy would add, “But we got John Maine!” Rimshot. The best I could muster was that he'd always had trouble initially moving up a level, and then found himself. That and the fact that the Orioles were stupid. I'm sure I was crossing my fingers while typing it.

March-May: The “Where?” Months. Jorge Julio was a disaster. Kris Benson was Kris Benson. John Maine was in St. Lucie and Norfolk. Boy was he old for 25.

May-June: John Maine Gives Us the Finger. With Brian Bannister on the shelf for a couple of extra weeks (hahahaha!), Maine was a surprise starter. Greg's postgame take after his National League debut: John Maine pitched OK. I guess we'll see him again. He wasn't really all that interesting. No, he wasn't. Then he was gone with some nebulous finger injury. When he came off the DL five weeks later, we packed him back off to Norfolk. By then Jorge Julio had gotten just good enough to send off to Arizona for El Duque. Our great hope at the back end of the rotation? It was Alay Soler. John Maine was back in his native Virginia, next to be glimpsed in St. Lucie or on the waiver wire. If we thought of him at all, it was grumpily while Kris and Anna celebrated his win and his homer and her mouth. “John who? Oh yeah — the other guy in the Benson-for-El Duque swap. Man, not sure that one was worth it. Maine, Maine…wasn't there something wrong with his finger?”

July: The Maybe Month. First Maine was bad. Then he got tired with too much game to go. Then he was lights-out. Then he was lights-out again. Hmmmm. You know, I never liked Kris Benson anyway.

August: We've Loved John Maine Our Whole Lives. Three in a row lost to Philadelphia, Pedro back on the shelf, Wright exhausted, Delgado lost, Cliff in St. Lucie, Jose all by his lonesome. Granted, not a situation dire enough to reconsider October plans, but all of a sudden baseball wasn't the giddy pleasure it's been most of this remarkable year. With a day game on tap, I found myself walking to the subway this morning thinking dark thoughts about our offense, about the Phillies, about whether Lastings could really learn on the job, about a hundred other Met-related anxieties medium and small. And then I heard a most unexpected little voice in my head, offering a bit of Faith amid all this Fear.

I like our chances — Maine's going today.

Yes, the same John Maine who'd been the other guy and one of the anonymous guys and the forgotten guy and the guy with the finger and the guy who replaced Soler after he was undressed by the Yankees because…well, because we didn't have anybody else.

And that same John Maine throttled the Phils, the lone blemish a Ryan Howard dinger. (Which is the kind of blemish that's had a lot of pitchers reaching for the Clearasil this year.) Wasn't nervous, didn't rattle, had a plan and stuck to it, showed his usual swing-and-a-miss stuff — the kind of stuff only El Duque has on this staff, and then only sometimes. Beat the Phillies like the Phillies deserve to be beaten. Sent us home (with some help from the Carloses) happy. Restored order. Left us thinking about the '86 Mets reunion (Strawberry flavoring added back in!) instead of about Bad Things.

The regular season has six weeks to go, and a lot can happen. So I'm not going to speculate on future acts in the American life of John Maine. But let's leave a placeholder for him, one we never thought we'd need, but that he's shown us he deserves.

October: __________________.

3 comments to What It Means to Be John Maine

  • Anonymous

    Assuming Maine pitches reasonably well for the rest of the season, do we trust him to start in the playoffs? I don't buy the reasoning that Trachsel has to be a starter in the postseason because he can't come out of the bullpen. Trachsel is a valuable commodity: he's a fourth or fifth starter who eats up innings. He's a .500 pitcher on a good team, and a loser on any other team. This year he's gotten lots of run support so his record is very good, but he's still not who I want starting in the playoffs.
    Pedro, if healthy, and Glavine obviously start playoff games. El Duque is a proven big game pitcher, so I think he should be given a chance to start, unless he's the designated stop-the-disaster reliever. I'd hate to put Maine in the bullpen just because Trachsel will go into a funk if he doesn't start. Trachsel seems to go into a funk if the toilet paper in the clubhouse comes off from behind the roll instead of from in front of the roll. I don't think the Mets rotation should be held hostage to his exquisite sensitivities.

  • Anonymous

    I'd rather have Maine than Trachsel. I'll happily have that thrown back in my face when Trachsel pitches our first no-hitter to win the World Series in Game 4 against the Tigers.

  • Anonymous

    To play pitching coach of the obvious for a moment, John Maine has to keep the ball down to be successful. The only runs he's actively allowed since he's gotten good are on home runs: three solo shots against Florida, the two homers in DC, Howard yesterday. He throws a lot of fly balls. That's all right at Shea. On the Sunday night game against Philly, he must have induced an out an inning to Lastings Milledge in right. If we find ourselves playing Game Three at Great American, I'd be a little nervous.
    That said, I'll be a little nervous no matter who's pitching where. I've been assuming since the year began that at some point somebody would step up and be what Bob Walk and Marty Bystrom were to Phillies teams that needed an extra arm to win pennants in the early 1980s. A rookie would come out of more or less nowhere and become a staple in the rotation. It was supposed to be Pelfrey, it turned out to be Maine. I can live with him, but he's gotta keep the ball down.