The blog for Mets fans
who like to read

ABOUT US

Jason Fry and Greg Prince
Faith and Fear in Flushing made its debut on Feb. 16, 2005, the brainchild of two longtime friends and lifelong Met fans.

Greg Prince discovered the Mets when he was 6, during the magical summer of 1969. He is a Long Island-based writer, editor and communications consultant. Contact him here.

Jason Fry is a Brooklyn writer whose first memories include his mom leaping up and down cheering for Rusty Staub. Check out his other writing here.

Got something to say? Leave a comment, or email us at faithandfear@gmail.com. (Sorry, but we have no interest in ads, sponsored content or guest posts.)

Need our RSS feed? It's here.

Visit our Facebook page, or drop by the personal pages for Greg and Jason.

Or follow us on Twitter: Here's Greg, and here's Jason.

You Get What You Give

Once upon a time, the spring of 1969, to be precise, the New York Mets were in the market for a hitter. Sure, other GMs told their Met counterpart Johnny Murphy, we’ll give you somebody. Names like Joe Torre, Richie Allen, even Frank Robinson were floated. All it would cost the Mets was young starting pitching. The Mets were loaded with young starting pitching. They had Tom Seaver, Jerry Koosman, Nolan Ryan, Gary Gentry, Jim McAndrew, plus a golden left arm in the minors, Jon Matlack. Trades were discussed. Trades were rejected. The pitching was protected.

One young Met pitcher would be dispatched in 1969, righty Steve Renko. Steve had been in the Met system since 1965, chosen in the 24th round of the very first June amateur draft, and was struggling at Triple-A Tidewater. Murphy apparently didn’t mind giving him up, since what Renko — along with Kevin Collins, Jay Carden and Dave Colon — brought back from Montreal was the kind of bat the general manager had been seeking all along: a real power hitter. The man who came to New York on June 15, 1969, was Donn Clendenon. Four months and one day later, Clendenon was accepting a 1970 Dodge Charger, his reward for being voted World Series MVP.

That trade worked out. It would always work out. When Renko and the Expos defeated McAndrew and the Mets at Jarry Park on June 26, 1970, it worked out. When Renko started a game at Shea that July in which Montreal eventually topped the Mets, it worked out. When, in the September heat of the 1970 pennant race, Renko threw a complete game in Canada to beat Seaver and the Mets, it never stopped working out.

Trading Steve Renko to the Expos for Donn Clendenon was a major step toward the Mets winning a World Series…toward winning the 1969 World Series, an achievement that forever defines this franchise for the good. Renko pitched through 1983 and won 134 big league games, nine of them at the expense of the team that drafted and traded him. Yet there was never a second of regret at having dealt 24-year-old Steve Renko away. It gave the Mets Clendenon. It gave the Mets a championship.

Friday night, John Gant, 23, won his first major league decision, a very effective 5-1 victory for the Atlanta Braves over the New York Mets. Gant is a Brave because the Mets sent him and Robert Whalen south last summer to obtain Juan Uribe and Kelly Johnson. At the time, the Mets had plenty of young starting pitching in the majors and too many minor leaguers filling their bench. They had to have Uribe and Johnson to push forward in a highly competitive pennant race. Gant was a 21st-round Met pick in 2011, taken three rounds sooner than Renko. He was at Double-A Binghamton in 2015, posting numbers no more eye-popping than those registered by Renko as a 1969 Tide. Never having seen Gant (or Whalen), I had no opinion of their prospects when Sandy Alderson opted to ship them off to the foundering Braves.

Within weeks, it was clearly the right trade for its time. Uribe and Johnson were exactly what the Mets needed in the moment. The moment would extend into November. The Mets won a division title and league championship. How we think of the Mets, as a team that is supposed to win ballgames, was utterly altered by what they accomplished in 2015. We are in a different space because of what all the players who steered the Mets into August and September did, few any more vital to the cause than the two erstwhile Atlanta utilitymen who chipped in big hit after big hit. That pennant is forever.

Just keep that in mind should Gant drop another six-and-two-thirds innings of two-hit ball on the Mets in the near or distant future. And when they play Detroit later this season, please refer to all of the above should we face 23-year-old Michael Fulmer, he of the current 7-2 record, 2.43 ERA and just-snapped 33⅓-inning scoreless streak. Fulmer, as you are no doubt aware, was the Met pitching prospect dealt to the Tigers to acquire Yoenis Cespedes. Yoenis Cespedes was the biggest reason the Mets roared into their first postseason in nine years. Fulmer might do wonderful things for Detroit and terrible things to our psyche in the years ahead. If Gant’s allegory is Renko, Fulmer’s might be Matlack, the first-round pick who was in demand, except Alderson, unlike Murphy, let him go for the bat the Mets desperately needed. Matlack was destined for a sensational career, most of it with our team. Fulmer has begun his run in spectacular fashion away from us.

We got Cespedes for him. We got to the World Series for the first time in fifteen years. It was worth it. It always will be.

By sheer coincidence, I’ll be at the Briarwood branch of the Queens Library, Saturday, June 25 at 3 PM to discuss Amazin’ seasons past and present. Hope you’ll join me.

10 comments to You Get What You Give

  • Dave

    Bingo, Greg. Just as the Mets have been on the opposite end of some of these deals – very successfully in some cases – people need to remember that some can’t miss prospects miss badly, and if the demand for them is high and the return can help the team at a time when it really matters, sometimes you have to pull the trigger. I don’t think anyone wound up wishing the Mets had kept Preston Wilson and passed up on a HOF catcher. Fulmer would be in Triple-A for the Mets right now and we’d all be wondering if he could be converted to a reliever…and we wouldn’t be the defending NL Champs.

    But where on Earth did Gant get that delivery? Don’t tell me we have minor league pitching coaches teaching that.

  • Mookie4ever

    You’re absolutely right, Greg, no matter how great all these young pitchers turn out to be, it’s all been worth it. But geez, do they have to keep turning on the afterburners against the Mets? You’d think they could show a little gratitude. Seems like the year of the ex-Mets. What’s next, a 2-hitter by Dillon Gee next week when KC comes to town?

  • Mikey

    This is great perspective greg. I wouldnt trade 2015 for having fulmer and gant languishing in aaa. We all wanted that big bat and he got us that and the extra pieces. And of course the other gms had a job to do too.

  • Eric

    Hopefully, Gant and Fulmer’s early success – along with the current Mets rotation – are indicators that the Mets system is ready to mold more raw pitching talent for MLB success for when attrition eats away the current starters. Hopefully, too, Wheeler proves that keeping him over Fulmer was the right decision.

    The Mets are slogging, but the Nationals haven’t lapped the field yet, and it’s comforting that the wildcard race is more usual this season.

  • eric1973

    I tend to evaluate decisions at the time they are made, rather than basing it on the results.

    To carry that to the extreme, if Colon hits a pinch-hit Grand Slam to win the game, it’s still a lousy decision —- just turned out right. So if Fulmer and Gant wind up going to the HOF, good luck to them, and they were still good moves, no matter the results.

  • Lenny65

    Steve Renko…now there’s a name I haven’t heard in a long time. I remember way, way back when they traded Ken Singleton (and Tim Foli and Mike Jorgensen) for Rusty Staub. I was outraged because Singleton was my favorite Met at that time, mainly because he had an allergy like I did (I was six). I think it was with the wool uniforms or something. That deal worked out pretty well. Foli and Jorgenson even came back eventually, as did Rusty, but that’s a whole other story. Mickey Lolich my ass.

    That’s a lot of two-time Mets in one deal, probably the most I bet. I’ll have to look into that during the next game, as I’ll need something entertaining to do while awaiting the daily injury news. The Mets are always so all-in. It’s not enough that one or two key guys get hurt, it has to be half the roster. One guy doesn’t hit a slump at a time, they all do, together. They’re either the most exciting or the least exciting, no middle ground.

  • RckyMtnEd

    Somehow get Cargo from the Rockies. Trade combo of either Wheeler, Conforto, Ynoa, Montero, Grandy, Lagares,Robles.Sign the Cuban 3rd baseman. Boom! (Drops the mic!)

  • […] the worst, which is saying something after how Saturday night went down. You can accept with grace one loss to a rebuilding entity like the Braves. You can rationalize away a second loss defined by a third […]

  • […] whole point of obsessing over all of this is to win the pennant, and ideally the World Series, too. Have a legitimate chance to win? Go for it, future consequences be […]

  • […] a triple. I’m not thrilled to have Niese back, but I’m thrilled to have Bastardo gone. In this funhouse mirror version of Fulmer for Cespedes, you apparently have to accept something to get rid of […]