The blog for Mets fans
who like to read


Greg Prince and Jason Fry
Faith and Fear in Flushing made its debut on Feb. 16, 2005, the brainchild of two longtime friends and lifelong Met fans.

Greg Prince discovered the Mets when he was 6, during the magical summer of 1969. He is a Long Island-based writer, editor and communications consultant. Contact him here.

Jason Fry is a Brooklyn writer whose first memories include his mom leaping up and down cheering for Rusty Staub. Check out his other writing here.

Got something to say? Leave a comment, or email us at (Sorry, but we have no interest in ads, sponsored content or guest posts.)

Need our RSS feed? It's here.

Visit our Facebook page, or drop by the personal pages for Greg and Jason.

Or follow us on Twitter: Here's Greg, and here's Jason.

15 Seconds of Lousy Baseball — We've Had Enough

Of course I thought of Buckner. As I watched slow-motion replay after slow-motion replay, I thought of Bob Costas' line that the Bill Buckner play, October 25, 1986, is the Zapruder film of American sports. The Luis Castillo dropped pop fly was now the ball through Bill Buckner's legs for the 21st century.

I thought of the Billy Wagner game from three years ago, May 20, 2006, how helpless that felt, how commanding Pedro Martinez was for seven innings — and Duaner Sanchez for an inning beyond that — and how all Wagner had to do was come in and not give up four runs to the Yankees. He gave up four runs. We lost after he left, in eleven.

I thought of Armando Benitez. I could have thought of a dozen Armando Benitez games, but I thought of one of his last appearances in a Mets uniform, a Subway Series Sunday night, walk after walk, destroying a Mets lead and creating the platform for an extra-inning Mets loss at which point everybody in the house had heartburn. Armando saved a lot of wins for the Mets but blew a lot of saves, too. Each blown save felt bigger than any ten he didn't blow. On that occasion, June 22, 2003, Stephanie, sitting up and battling fierce indigestion that got her out of bed, asked, “if he keeps doing this, why do they keep him?”

I thought of Looper, Pittsburgh, July 8, 2005. It wasn't the Yankees. It didn't have to be.

I thought of and sputtered on as part of my post-Castillo pillow-throwing rant (hey, they're throw pillows) to Stephanie about the Jets. The Jets? Why on earth the Jets? Because this was pretty Jetslike. This was January 3, 1987, the Jets with a ten-point lead on the Browns, some four minutes from going to the AFC championship. Then Gastineau roughs Kosar and Cleveland has new life and two overtimes later, it's the Browns who will move on to face the Broncos and it is the Jets who I will never, ever again trust with a lead until 0:00 is on the clock.

They're not the only ones.

I thought of earlier in the evening, being out at a local Italian restaurant for my brother-in-law's birthday, a man thoughtful enough to have reserved me the seat that faced the TV. I watched the Mets take a 6-3 lead on Sheffield's fifth-inning blast and celebrated for about a minute and then turned dark. “Y'know what the problem with my mind here is?” I said to my baseball-oblivious sister. “I can't enjoy the Mets having a lead because now all I can do is worry that the Yankees will come back and before I know it, we'll be losing 7-6.” Which we were shortly after we got home and Jon Switzer became a Met.

And I thought of Francisco Rodriguez who, it was being noted by Gary Cohen as the Yankees celebrated their improbable…no, impossible comeback, had technically blown his first save as a Met. At that instant I didn't ache for myself as a Mets fan and I didn't ache for the Mets. I ached for K-Rod. This CANNOT be a blown save for Francisco Rodriguez! I squealed. How? How? I'm used to saves being blown by Mets closers who were congenitally incapable of closing consistently — Wagner, Benitez, Looper, the grand old man Franco — but that wasn't this. Frankie Rodriguez did his job. If Omar Minaya has done anything exquisitely in his almost five years as general manager of the New York Mets, it was sign this man, this closer, this bastion of perfection who has flourished in a pool of incompetence all season long.

A BS for K-Rod? BS, indeed.

I thought about Luis Castillo, but not out of empathy. I was empathetic toward Luis Castillo in 2008, even as I wished to see him remain sidelined for his and our own good. Luis Castillo was a one-man Mets bullpen last September. You did not want to them in a game and you did not want to see him in a game. That's why we got Damion Easley until he could no longer trudge out to second. That's why we got Argenis Reyes and Ramon Martinez even though one was woefully undercooked and the other was practically done. If Omar Minaya has done anything abominably in his almost five years as general manager of the New York Mets, it was to sign this man. In 2007, Luis Castillo was ineffectual. In 2008, Luis Castillo was a sad sack. In 2009, as he soared to bare adequacy, I could have sworn Luis Castillo was a Comeback Player of the Year candidate.

Now he is no longer barely adequate.

I imagine Luis Castillo comes to work Saturday and greets Ryan Church and Daniel Murphy, among others. I imagine their conversation will be self-satisfying to all involved.

“Guys, you think I'm in trouble?”

“Gee, Luis, I missed third base to cost us a game, but nothing bad happened to me. I got to keep playing.”

“Yeah, Luis, I dropped several fly balls, but nothing bad happened to me. I got to keep playing.”

“That's good, fellas. Because I just committed as egregious sin on the baseball diamond as could be imagined, but I guess I'll get to keep playing, too.”

“Of course you will, Luis. This is the Mets. There are no consequences for failure to execute the easiest and most vital steps that are part and parcel of winning baseball games. Maybe on other teams those miscues are frowned upon, but here only the fans get worked up about them. Our supervisors look the other way.”

“Yes, Luis, it's true. They are either very forgiving or have exceedingly low expectations where results are concerned. In fact I'm assuming that like almost every day here, we won't have to take infield or do anything other than go through the motions for a few hours before we can shower and leave.”

“We still get paid, right? I'm due $15.5 million over the next 2½ years and I have all kinds of uses for my absurdly high salary.”

“Luis, I'm surprised you'd ask these questions. You were of virtually no help to the team last year — most would say you were a detriment — and I'm guessing you didn't miss a single paycheck.”

“That's true, Ryan. I was compensated in a timely and lucrative manner.”

“Then relax. We're very good at that here.”

“I know. But what I did last night — drop a most simple popup that our closer worked so hard to generate for what was supposed to be the last out…and against the one rival who our fans so hate for us to lose to — I thought there might be a penalty.”

“Despite my near-rookie status, I don't think that's a problem, Luis. Maybe you get moved to a new position…”

“No Daniel, unlike you, I don't have even perceived versatility working for me.”

“Then I think you just get paid and everybody acts like nothing ever happened.”


“Isn't it, though?”

Not cool. Not cool the way most of the Mets play. Not cool that Castillo was fooled by a most guileless ball. Not cool that once he got his footing and was under it, he used exactly one hand — half of his quota — to secure it. Not cool that he did not secure it. Not cool that instead of grabbing the ball and firing it home, he tossed it mindlessly to second base where there was no play. Not cool that as a Mets fan I thought the trail runner on the play would only be at third base. As a Mets fan, after all, I know very well that a player who is on first base when a ball is popped to shallow right/deep second with two outs isn't going to run very hard.

I forgot it was a Yankee running all the way from first base. Of course Mark Teixeira scored. The Yankees do that. The one thing I'll never take away from the Yankees is that somebody somewhere instilled that ethic into them. You run, you run, you run. Teixeira ran on an impossible play and thus scored because somebody teaches him and his teammates that nothing's impossible in baseball.

Not when you're playing the Mets.

The dismalness of this experience was a thousand percent enhanced by the fact that it was the Subway Series, that we wound up losing a game we were about to win to the Yankees, but the Castillo dropped pop fly transcends even the opponent. We've grown up since the early days of Interleague play when making a stand in the face of the pinstriped propaganda apparatus seemed paramount. This wasn't that Friday night, not in 2009. We're supposed to be a big-time contender as a matter of course, whatever city we're playing our road games in on a given weekend. This wasn't about attaining braggin' rights or a Mayor's Trophy. This was about winning a baseball game, something the Mets did not do. You can't win 'em all, you've heard, and that is true. But you can operate in a manner in which attempting to win every single game you play in is your most obvious priority.

The Mets aren't in that business, which is a bad fit considering they're a baseball team.

What business are the Mets in exactly? I ask that quite seriously. If the Mets are in the business of winning baseball games rather than putting on airs to project an impression that they are interested in winning baseball games, then Omar Minaya releases Luis Castillo before today's first pitch. Then, when that is done, Fred Wilpon releases Omar Minaya and Jerry Manuel. And if a commission could be convened to find the Mets a new owner, that wouldn't be the worst idea in the world either.

Break up the Mets. For their own good, break up the Mets. Break off a piece of the Mets at any rate. Dismiss the most blatant offender. Dismiss Luis Castillo. Tell some lucky Buffalo Bison or Savannah Sand Gant he is now the second baseman in Flushing. Tell Luis Castillo, however, that he no longer plays for the New York Mets. Tell him and his erstwhile teammates that there have to be some minimal standards for maintaining membership on this team and that not catching a catchable pop fly for the final out is that standard — a standard that could be overlooked this one time if he had made good on his Pee Wee League error and thrown home. But he didn't do that either.

What does it take to not be a Met? Is this enough? Is not making that play enough? He doesn't make that play in the second inning against the Padres, or even the Yankees, we say, well, OK, these things happen. But c'mon, this is crunch time. You don't have to be Wise, the Official Potato Chip of the New York Mets, to understand the concept of crunch time. You, Mr. Veteran Second Baseman with three Gold Gloves gathering dust on your mantel, are paid to catch that ball.

You are paid to not allow a blown save onto Francisco Rodriguez's ledger if Francisco Rodriguez did not blow the save. Frankie will blow a save eventually. He will blow several over the course of his contract, and we will deal with that reality when it occurs. But you, Luis Castillo, committed not just an error, but a sin. You did not support your teammate. I don't mean you didn't issue some worthless stream of quotes after the game. You didn't back him up with your glove. Not in the second inning, but in the ninth inning. We have Frankie Rodriguez so we don't have those Wagner, Benitez, Looper moments. The frustration of watching a solid to spectacular start swirl down the drain is immeasurable. It was unspeakably deflating when Pedro would be no-decisioned because of Looper or Wagner, or Johan came away empty-handed because of Billy the Kid…and never mind their W-L. The team W-L took a hit. Frankie's the barrier to that happening more than rarely between now and 2012.

Yet you, Luis, you conked Frankie over the head with that barrier. He did his job. One out, a single to Jeter, another out, Jeter steals second, 3-1 to Teixeira, an intentional ball four, then Alex Rodriguez, Mr. Clutch. K-Rod popped up A-Rod. That's doin' the job. That's exactly why K-Rod was such an acquisition. Wagner and Looper and Benitez and sleepless nights extending back to John Franco…it was no sleep 'til K-Rod. But he did exactly what he had to do.

You didn't. You did the opposite.

The other night Carlos Beltran misplayed a ball in center field that led to some Phillie runs. It did not occur to me that Carlos Beltran should be released. You don't weigh one misplay against a portfolio bulging with sensational catches and bountiful hitting. Luis Castillo is not Carlos Beltran. Luis Castillo is usually adequate. Once in a while he is adequate-plus. Thursday night he collected three hits and scored three runs and flashed a bit of leather. That was very nice, but it's not enough to counterbalance Friday night. Friday night was Monster Chiller Horror Theatre and our second baseman was Count Luis, sucking the blood from victory. His act must be cancelled.

This is not a call for Jihad against Luis Castillo per se. I've got nothing against him personally. I felt bad he was such a target for boos in 2008 partly out of sympathy and partly out of utility. I don't think booing a Met will help a Met and we tend to need all the help we can get. But it doesn't help the Mets, plural, to continue to foster a roster of zombie players who make some of the most embarrassing, unprofessional and deleterious mistakes a baseball player can make. Everybody who makes them — like Church, like Murphy, like Fernando Martinez — is essentially patted on the back and/or the head and is told that's all right, you get to keep playing for us.

Is that the plan for Luis Castillo? Is he, like everyone else on this team, given a pass for what has bulleted to the top of the Worst Play Ever charts? Are the New York Mets in the business of winning baseball games? Or are they just putting on airs?

While I was thinking about Buckner and Wagner and the Jets blowing it in Cleveland, I watched the postgame show on SNY. Bobby Ojeda, Darryl Strawberry and Chris Carlin at once closed ranks and praised Luis Castillo to the hilt for standing at his locker and speaking to reporters. I feel bad, Castillo said. I thought I had it, Castillo said. I have to catch that ball, Castillo said.

He looked very sad. He's a human being and you can't help but wish a human being who is not in the opposition's uniform not look that sad. But honestly, I don't care that he stood at his locker and admitted culpability. Geez, are our standards for performance that low that blowing it and then saying “I blew it” earns you credit?

Not here it doesn't. Make a vital mistake in building a car so the car breaks down, you shouldn't be on the line any longer. Make a vital mistake with a prescription or a ligament, then mister, you shouldn't be a doctor. Be the Met who can't catch the game-ending popup against the Yankees, you can't be a Met in the next game. You just can't. I'm trying to be reasonable and not hair trigger in recommending this course of action, but sometimes it's reasonable to do what appears drastic.

Next week, when Luis Castillo shouldn't still be a Met but probably will be, the Tampa Bay Rays will come to Citi Field. Every beat guy will write a Scott Kazmir story, even if Scott Kazmir is on the DL. You'll recall the trade of Scott Kazmir for Victor Zambrano raised a firestorm of dismay and disgust among Mets watchers in 2004. It was nothing but bad in most eyes (not mine; I reflexively concluded Kazmir was an overblown Mets pitching prospect in the tradition of every Mets pitching prospect for a decade) but later its narrative got a fresh coat of rationalization. Yeah, Scott Kazmir was a bad trade, but it moved the Mets to act positively. It brought in Minaya who brought in Martinez and Beltran and we all began to live happily ever after.

Could a dropped pop fly, a mindless toss to second and two hustling Yankee baserunners have the same effect in 2009 that Jim Duquette's front office bobble in 2004 had in terms of righting the ship? Could this be, to cross over to football again, the baseball equivalent of the most infamous moment in Giants history, the one from November 19, 1978 when Joe Pisarcik muffed an unnecessary handoff to Larry Csonka? Remember or at least read about that one?

The Giants were about to put away the Eagles. All they had to do was take a knee; fall on the ball. Inexplicably, the order was sent down from the press box not to do what every team did with the clock running down — hand it to Csonka, that's the ticket. Pisarcik handed the ball to Csonka's hip instead. The ball fell to the Meadowlands turf, Herman Edwards picked it up for Philadelphia and romped into the end zone. The score went from 17-12 Giants to 19-17 Eagles in an eyeblink. The subsequent scream, when prorated to 2009 Mets levels, may have been the harshest I let out until 8-7 Mets became 9-8 Yankees on June 12, 2009.

The Giants, who hadn't made the playoffs since 1963, were on the fringe of the NFC Wild Card race until that football slipped free. When what happened happened, their competitive aspirations died yet again. What followed was a firestorm that made the Kazmir controversy look like Cap Day. Bob Gibson, the Giants offensive coordinator who was pressured to call the handoff from director of football operations Andy Robustelli, was let go the next day. Fans — which is to say people who had been with the team for generations — burned their season tickets in the Giants Stadium parking lot. Most memorably, a plane was hired to carry a banner: 15 YEARS OF LOUSY FOOTBALL — WE'VE HAD ENOUGH.

Enough was enough. Robustelli, a great old Giant from their last glory epoch, was fired. Head coach John McVay was fired. NFL commissioner Pete Rozelle stepped in and facilitated the hiring of GM George Young. Young hired head coach Ray Perkins. They drafted Phil Simms (who replaced Pisarcik early in the 1979 season). Perkins' defensive coordinator was Bill Parcells. I realize this is a digression about football from thirty years ago, and more Mets fans are Jets fans than Giants fans, but I'm guessing you can see the point: from utter disaster came deliverance. Parcells would succeed Perkins. Young would steer the organization to a series of successful drafts, including that of Lawrence Taylor. There would be growing pains, but there was a powerhouse rising in the swamp. Eight years after Pisarcik couldn't hand the ball to Csonka, Simms brought a Super Bowl trophy home to East Rutherford.

The Giants were far more of a mess in 1978 than the Mets are presently, but the Mets do not appear to be heading in a super direction for the long term. The Minaya era has peaked. Jerry Manuel has peaked. Luis Castillo has peaked. In the time it took Alex Rodriguez's pop fly to peak, descend and bounce away — 15 seconds of lousy baseball at most — it became crystal clear to me that this is a Pisarcik moment.

This is a team that needs to start being saved from itself at once. This is an organization that needs a modern-day Gil Hodges to march out to second base and tell Luis Castillo that his leg isn't quite right, you're leaving the game. Except Luis needs to leave the clubhouse and keep walking. Don't cry for him, Lou Castillo — he'll still get paid his $15.5 million whether he's here drifting uncomfortably under pop flies until he's not catching them with two hands or not. We're getting Sheffield for almost free, so look at eating Castillo's contract as good financial karma.

In late April, I pondered the future of this team and wondered if it was being well-served by its core. I now realize my concerns were misplaced. The Mets' core is not Beltran, Wright and Reyes. The Mets' core is complacency, ineptitude and unaccountability. That trio is locked in here unless something is done to remove them. If Wellington and Tim Mara could be made to understand they weren't doing themselves any favors by keeping those who had failed them around, Fred and Jeff Wilpon can, too.

Omar Minaya can no longer be graded for what he did between December 2004 and January 2006 when his deals yielded Pedro, the Carloses, Wagner, Lo Duca, Sanchez, Nady and Maine. It is 2009. He brought in Frankie Rodriguez. That's one big check mark in his favor. He also constructed a roster and a depth chart behind it that was ill-equipped to handle adversity and injury. That's a huge minus. He has run an organization where slothfulness is nurtured and tolerated. That's an outsized minus. He has created a team of four or five stars and as many as seventeen or eighteen journeymen. Mark that a minus, too. Omar Minaya isn't helping the Mets win baseball games.

Jerry Manuel? Isn't Jerry Manuel responsible for the way his team plays? For not touching third and not catching flies and not running to first and not sliding home and not knowing enough to use two hands or to throw to the right base? Why don't they take infield every day? Why don't they make it around the bases when they're on the bases? What was Jon Switzer doing in there against Hideki Matsui besides a Mel Rojas impersonation? Jerry Manuel isn't helping the Mets win baseball games.

Luis Castillo? Until Friday night, not the Mets' biggest problem. But he's bearing the brunt now. Luis Castillo did not help the Mets win a very big ballgame. In fact, he lost it for them not because he isn't good enough but because he didn't play well enough. There's a difference.

If you're not helping us win baseball games, you're hurting us. If you're hurting us, you shouldn't be here. I don't know why anyone would run a baseball team any other way.

METSTOCK: 3 Hours of Pizza and Baseball is coming to Manhattan on Thursday, June 18, 7:00 PM. Meet the authors of A Magic Summer, Mets By The Numbers and Faith and Fear in Flushing: An Intense Personal History of the New York Mets, talk baseball with us, watch the Mets beat the Orioles just as they did in '69 with us and have a generally great time. Details here.

Faith and Fear in Flushing: An Intense Personal History of the New York Mets is available from Amazon, Barnes & Noble or a bookstore near you. Keep in touch and join the discussion on Facebook.

33 comments to 15 Seconds of Lousy Baseball — We've Had Enough

  • Anonymous

    As we've seen so many times before, the very worst of the Mets brings out your best, Greg.

  • Anonymous

    This would seem like a good time to go to Puerto Rico for three days. Hang in there, everybody.

  • Anonymous

    I'm still ill over this…. This one affects me even more than that curve ball that froze Beltran….

  • Anonymous

    that's great stuff, as usual, Greg… Unfortunately, the thought of Luis Castillo being on this team makes me ill beyond words…
    As Mets fans, we can only hope that this game leads to the same upheaval as the Pisarcik game did. Unfortunately, I don't think that's the case. This is a team that is rotten to its core, from the top down. With owners who care less about winning than having a team that just good enough to give us enough reason to separate our money from wallets… I fear that neither Omar or Jerry will go anywhere anytime soon…

  • Anonymous

    I think that was quite possibly the worst Mets loss I've ever seen – it certainly comes close to the bases loaded walk. Nice piece.

  • Anonymous

    The Mets finally have a new marketing slogan:
    “We have met the enemy, and he is us.”
    Un. Fucking. Believable.

  • Anonymous

    Hi Greg,
    OK if I share with your readers the angry letter I wrote last night to Louis but didn't have the courage to send? (Even if not, I'm sharing it anyway – LOL).
    “Dear Louie:
    I still can't believe what I saw. Damn you, Castillo. Our rag-tag unit fights hard, trying to keep pace with the Phillies with our key players on
    the disabled list and they do only to have you drop a simple, game ending
    pop-up? And to the Yankees. Any other team but not to the Yankees!
    Don't look to me any more for solace or support. We're not going to be able to live this one down for quite a long time since you gave John
    Sterling and his cohorts enough ammunition to throw this one back in our
    faces but good.
    And thank you for kicking us in the stomach and ripping the heart out of the Subway Series. We were patient and let Chamberlain walk his way to the showers. We got clutch hits. We fought back. KRod made his pitches when they counted. And for what? I'm so disgusted that I can't wait for the series to be over.
    You're not Bill Buckner playing on bad legs. I hope you're booed out of
    New York but good. Don't care if we don't have anyone else to play second, I just want to be rid of you.
    Best wishes always,
    P.S. This isn't personal — it's strictly business. Say hi to the family for me”

  • Anonymous

    i have been a mets fan since the polo grounds. but this is the last straw. until the org gets it in order i aint wachin or going to any games.

  • Anonymous

    I had all night to think about it, and I agree. Eat the $15 million left on that contract, bring up a warm body, and move on. That's the only way to send the right message. If they trot him back out there, I'm done, at least for a few weeks if not longer.

  • Anonymous

    So am I and I thought I saw it all.
    Remember another Friday night game, this one early in 1965 in St. Louis? The Mets scored five in the first and were still leading 5-2 with two out in the bottom of the ninth inning when Ron Swoboda dropped an easy fly to right with the bases loaded enabling the Cards to tie the game (they eventually went on to win).
    The next day Dick Young wrote “Ron Swobada hits homers with his bat and triples with his glove”.
    Back then the Mets under Casey were lovable. It was more funny than anything else and we always forgave them. It's not so now.

  • Anonymous

    You've said in 4,000 everything I've felt over the last three years. I've had enough of this pathetic baseball and this pathetic team. It's time for some fundamental changes.

  • Anonymous

    Masterful piece, Greg. This is what millions should have the opportunity to read in their morning papers and you should be getting paid for it. The fact that you can't read analysis this good in the paper may be one of the reasons they're going out of business.
    And of course you're right. It's hard for anyone to make excuses any more. I don't think any player who is otherwise playing above expectations should be let go for one bad play, however bad it is. But there is no excuse for Jerry Manuel not to blow up at him and call him out the way you have. There is no excuse for not punishing him in some way that makes it clear that this can never happen again. The same would have been true of Murphy and Martinez as well. You can't blame a guy for making an error. But mental mistakes have to have consequences. There was no excuse for not using his right hand. There was no excuse for not throwing home. Players become better players if they learn something.

  • Anonymous

    I completely agree about the need to get rid of Castillo. I feel for him but this is one of those things that can't be repaired. He needs to go. On that level, this was a good piece. However, the comparison to Church and Murphy make absolutely no sense whatsoever. Murphy is not an outfielder and never will be. You can debate whether he should be playing at all but to compare his playing to Castillo's play is absurd. Church, for his part, made a bad mistake but even still the two plays are incomparable. This was a pop fly against the Yankees. Castillo played terribly last year after being rewarded a huge contract. Church played great last year until he had his unfortunate incidents. The Mets thereafter treated him like garbage and continue to do so. no comparison whatsoever. Those two points were out of place in the article – Castillo is not a bad guy and an average baseball player but he can't be on the Mets anymore – he stands alone.

  • Anonymous

    Joe, did I just hear you call in to WFAN?
    Greg, thanks for this post. It's helping me understand what should happen (that probably wont), rather than try to cope with what did happen.

  • Anonymous

    I'm not defending Castillo, but you can all be sure he's more pissed off at himself than you are.
    This is not a team of destiny and assumed late-innings heroics. Any and all runs and wins need to be scratched out and earned.
    In trying to find a closing message, I remember working with Greg, and occasionally he would shimmy into the office wearing his MC Hammer pants, boombox on his shoulder, playing that seminal Big Daddy Kane ditty, “Ain't No Half Steppin”.
    Ain't No Half Steppin, indeed.

  • Anonymous

    Jerry is the guy who has inherited and fostered this lazy, hot-dog, apathetic culture. And he's a terrible game manager. Fire him today. That would be “gangsta”. Six years of three bad managers is enough.

  • Anonymous

    Yeah, I agree. Also, Manuel is still taking tons of flak from fans who say Murphy's problem is that he's not getting enough playing time. That's yet another situation where Manuel can't win, no matter what he does, with a big portion of the team's fan base.
    Greg, I certainly understand the frustration, but I don't get how it's possible to simultaneously complain about how Minaya didn't put together a team with enough depth and complain about how Manuel is managing that team through a really difficult spate of injuries, considering he's kept them within 3 games of the Phillies so far this season.
    Personally, I think Minaya had very limited money to work with this offseason. The Wilpons lost hundreds of millions to Bernie Madoff. There were questions about whether they would even be able to afford to keep the team at all. (What's the solution to that? Change ownership? Who has the money and interest to buy an MLB team right now?) It would have been great if we'd gotten Orlando Hudson. The team couldn't afford him (due, admittedly, to Castillo's contract). It would have been great to get Derek Lowe, but the Braves SERIOUSLY overpaid for the one or two good seasons they'll probably get out of him. Manny Ramirez? That massive contract didn't work out as planned for the Dodgers. The Yankees paid through the nose for every other big free agent.
    But, complain about Minaya all you want. I still don't see how two heartbreakers to the Phillies and one horrible play by Castillo merit throwing Manuel and the rest of the team under a bus. If you sincerely do not believe this team, as currently constructed, has any hope of contention this season, what's Manuel supposed to do? Put Fernando Martinez into a time machine that instantly turns him into a 28 year old five-tool all-star? Put Ramon Martinez at second base and ride him till he wins a gold glove and hits 30 home runs this season? (Oh wait, he's on the DL, too.)
    Excuses aside, the team's still 3 games out of first, and still clinging to a winning record more than a third of the way through the season, despite a ton of injuries and not a whole lot of good options in their minor league system. To me, that means Manuel IS doing a good job.

  • Anonymous

    Oh Greg. greg, greg, greg. I have been dining my guts over how I was going to put into words what I was feeling since last night. I hardly slept. I feel like shit. I punched some bags this morning. I come here and I laughed. I cried. I felt better. Not much, but better. Thank you for putting into words exactly how every Mets fan must feel right now. And yes, cut Castillo. I don't care if we have to bat 8 and have Murphy cover 1st and 2nd. If we don't have him offense, what the hell else do we have him for??

  • Anonymous

    Remember the scene towards the end of “Goodfellas”, when Henry turns to Paulie for money and Paulie tells Henry that now he has to turn his back on him? That's exactly how I feel towards the Mets today. I cannot invest any more time or emotion in this bunch, at least for the time being, anyway. I can handle losing, it's the completely demoralizing and spirit-crushing way they do it that's pushed me past the point of rationality. It's too much. A scriptwriter could not have created a worse nightmare scenario than last night's debacle. It was easily the most crushing regular season loss I've ever witnessed.

  • Anonymous

    “Of course you will, Luis. This is the Mets. There are no consequences for failure to execute the easiest and most vital steps that are part and parcel of winning baseball games. Maybe on other teams those miscues are frowned upon, but here only the fans get worked up about them. Our supervisors look the other way.”
    This is why you're a great writer Greg. My son and I were talking about this same thing this morning. And over 12 hours later, I'm still sick about this fucking loss.

  • Anonymous

    I have really reached the breaking point with this team and this ownership.
    How does an organization spend so much and get so little in return? How are there so many fat, lazy, incompetent players who freeze up in the clutch on a team that is supposed to be a contender?
    How do the Dodgers lose Manny Ramirez and still play decent baseball while the Mets go in the tank at the slightest sign of adversity?
    How do the Red Sox develop a fantastic farm system and players who shine in the spotlight despite having low draft picks, while the Mets develop exactly THREE decent homegrown prospects in 25 years (Alfonzo, Wright and to a degree Reyes)? Even the most of heralded prospects they've traded away haven't been that great (wasn't Lastings Milledge supposed to be a super talent?)
    How is it the Mets think it's a good idea to keep an over-the-hill first baseman based on three decent months instead of signing the bland but competent Mark Texiera?
    Why is it that in each of the last three off-seasons, instead of trying to upgrade the team as a whole, they have been satisfied with one splashy acquisition while more holes remain unfilled?
    Why is it that Willie Randolph was allowed to stay after 2007 when the Red Sox learned their lesson and cut Grady Little loose after a similar collapse?
    Why is it that ownership feels the best design for a new ballpark is to copy a ballpark from a different team that hasn't played in New York in over 50 years?
    The one common thread I see here is the Wilpons. All of this happened on their watch. They may have saved the franchise in the early 80s, but since then it has always been a day late and a dollar short.
    No wonder they were duped by Bernie Madoff. They've been duped by Omar Minaya, Mo Vaughn, Art Howe and countless others over the years. The only way things will change is if ownership changes, and that just isn't happening. I just don't know if it's worth it to deal with this crap any more.

  • Anonymous

    To add a little extra misery to the equation, today we have to endure the inevitable verbal shitstorm from some combination of the intolerable McCarver, Buck, Karros, and that moron, Ken Rosenthal. They will tell us how it was Derek Jeter, through sheer force of will, that caused Castillo to drop that ball.

  • Anonymous

    Nope, wasn't me.
    That Joe D. calls the FAN often and I always wondered if someone might think it was me.
    But thanks all the same — it's nice to be remembered! :) :)

  • Anonymous

    Nobody should blame the other 24 Mets and Omar Minya for last night's fiasco. Let's stay focused – Castillo lost the game for us.
    Nobody, absolutely nobody, is calling this a Yankee victory or another come from behind win. In fact, this will probably be the only time I'll congratulate Yankee fans. Give them their due, for even though the crowd roared last night they are admitting getting an underserved gift and are instead being critical of Girardi for his moves, Rodriguez for twice not coming through, Chamberlain for his wildness and the Yankee bullpen in general for allowing the Mets to chip their way back.

  • Anonymous

    My half-assed response, which I'll probably have to edit after tonight's game:

  • Anonymous

    I can't sleep and I can't watch the Mets sleepwalk through this week's rebroadcast of last June's Wagnerian meltdown. I did not think there was anything that could make people stop caring about the Mets, but I've heard from 10 people this week that they're taking “time away” from the team. I'm breaking the Greg Commandments, typing this oblivious and not caring about the game in progress, fixing up the light socket I hit too hard last night (sorry, honey–and I too let out a shriek at a pitch I did not know I possessed)–and I'm going to bed early. I'll be back.

  • Anonymous

    I'm back (four hours later). How do I miss the four-run win and watch the one from hell? Ah, tis the path of the Mets fan.

  • Anonymous

    Well, it's damn hard to defend Castillo. Don't think I can do it. I was on him all year last year, and this year somewhat as well. I keep repeating to anyone who'll listen, “at some point, management has to step in and tell him he's not a switch hitter anymore. Can we please stop seeing the old 'square-around-on-every-other-pitch-to-distract-the-pitcher' routine?” But I never thought it would be a piece of routine defense that would be making me nauseous.
    That said, let's keep some perspective. If this weren't the Yankees, if we all weren't going to be hearing about this from our neighbors and co-workers for years to come, we would not be calling for anyone's release. Errors happen. They suck, and there isn't really any excuse for dropping a routine pop-up, ESPECIALLY WHEN YOU ONE-HAND IT, but it happens. I know (or I THINK) that Greg's post is a good dose of hyperbole, and maybe it's cathartic, but no club would — or should — release a player over one play, especially one that does not end a season.
    It sure would be nice, though, to never see one of these jokers try to one-hand a routine pop-up again. Heck, I thought we were over that swagger when Delgado dropped his. FUNDAMENTALS!

  • Anonymous

    I'm not trying to shill for readers, but I wish all of you would come over to my place and comment, because there is no indignation by my frickin' commenters. I said that while I didn't want blood, I wanted SOME kind of ire, some kind of disgust, some kind of response that shows me that they ALL understand what it meant to Mets fans for us to lose that game in the way that we did. Not David Wright saying “Oh, I am sure poor Luis just feels terrible,” not Jay Horwitz barring the media from talking to Castillo “until he's ready to talk”. None of it.
    The only good thing about that win was that it was so pathetic that we didn't get hassled on our way out of the house of evil or on the way to the train or on the platform or on the train. It was just QUIET. oddly, strangely quiet.
    What happened Friday night in the Bronx is a metaphor for the 2009 season. Mark my words.

  • Anonymous

    Interesting how you feel for Frankie, but not David, who was robbed of his second game-winning hit in the last 3 days after the ludicrous Francessa-fueled assault on his “clutch” abilities. You really don't like the guy, do you?

  • Anonymous

    David still has his RBI and doesn't get charged with a “blown run” or anything like that. He did his job and the boxscore reflects that. Frankie did his job and the boxscore says he doesn't. That's what hit me after the game.

  • Anonymous

    I love your description of the Bill Buckner snafu as the Zapruder film of sports. That is hilarious — and very true. That incident (one I never tire of, by the way) is included in a great book on sports “blunders,” What Were They Thinking? “The Brainless Blunders that Changed Sports History,” by sportswriter Kyle Garlett. Buckner is just one of many incidents — and Garlett takes the position Buckner is NOT to blame for the Red Sox losing the Series that year. It's a pretty fun book.

  • Anonymous

    I am not sure why anyone thinks Jerry could say anything to Castillo now that would change anything. I am also not sure what he could have said to Castillo before that that would have prevented it from happening.
    Castillo had an errorless streak in recent memory that lasted four years. Any manager on earth would have assumed that a guy like that knew exactly what he was doing with the glove. And it's not like he's at all likely to do it again; in fact, Jerry getting on his case in public makes it more likely that a similar fuckup will occur, not less.
    I'm pretty sure he got an earful from Frankie, and Frankie is exactly who SHOULD air out Castillo in a situation like this. Not the manager. Castillo is 33 years old. He's been in the majors since 1996. Veteran players don't take well at all to being treated like n00bs by their managers; they will not “play harder” as a result, quite the opposite. Johnny Keane found out the hard way when he went from a young Cardinals team that respected him to an old Yankees team that didn't. And Art Howe learned the same lesson on this very team just a few years back.
    Jerry may not be much of a strategist, but neither is Bobby Cox, and he's not going to lose HIS job any time soon. (Don't kid yourself; those Braves teams were packed with talent and kept finishing first in spite of Cox, not because of him.) White guys are allowed to suck; black guys had better be perfect if they want to keep their jobs or get another one after they get shitcanned. You really think there's a manager who's available right now who would have this team — with its injuries out the wazoo — in first place as we speak? Who? (Remember, Bobby Valentine never had a first-place finish.)
    As for whether Mets fans have learned much in the last 10 years about running guys out of town on a rail for bad glovework, I have two words for you: Melvin Mora. Sure, give Castillo away to the Cardinals. Watch what happens when it's us and St. Louis battling it out for the WC. And then y'all can rail at Omar for actually being dumb enough to listen to the fans.