The blog for Mets fans
who like to read


Greg Prince and Jason Fry
Faith and Fear in Flushing made its debut on Feb. 16, 2005, the brainchild of two longtime friends and lifelong Met fans.

Greg Prince discovered the Mets when he was 6, during the magical summer of 1969. He is a Long Island-based writer, editor and communications consultant. Contact him here.

Jason Fry is a Brooklyn writer whose first memories include his mom leaping up and down cheering for Rusty Staub. Check out his other writing here.

Got something to say? Leave a comment, or email us at (Sorry, but we have no interest in ads, sponsored content or guest posts.)

Need our RSS feed? It's here.

Visit our Facebook page, or drop by the personal pages for Greg and Jason.

Or follow us on Twitter: Here's Greg, and here's Jason.

The First Met of the Next Decade

What did I miss? When did Jason Bay become Dave Gallagher?

We’re getting a three-time All-Star here, and not an All-Star in the sense that Gary Sheffield was stellar in Paleozoic times. We’re not getting some overblown fourth outfielder. We’re getting a guy who has played five full seasons and has driven in more than 100 runs in four of them, which appears pretty impressive considering many of his swings occurred while surrounded by Pittsburgh Pirates.

Jason Bay is a major league outfielder. We’re not converting Keith Miller from the infield or handing Daniel Murphy a treasure map and praying he’ll find a ball while he’s out there. Jason Bay survived a large left field wall in Boston. Didn’t fall down as a matter of course and was known to occasionally hit pitches off or over it.

This is an upgrade over the 2009 situation in left field. This is an upgrade over the 2008 situation in left field. He may not be as lethal with the line drives as Moises Alou when Moises Alou was healthy, but remind me of how many weeks Moises Alou was healthy. Jason Bay is capable of giving us our most consistent production at his position since Cliff Floyd was in one piece, which, sadly, wasn’t all that often. He won’t jump over fences like Endy Chavez, but the fences at Citi Field might thwart even Endy.

I’m happy to have Jason Bay coming to the Mets, assuming he passes what I hope is a rigorous physical conducted a third-party medical staff. Mind you, I’m not overwhelmed by his presence. He’s not a franchise player, but he’s performed at a high level for quite a while now and he’s not in his early forties. Thus, I ask innocently, what’s the problem, exactly? I wouldn’t give him whatever exorbitant amount they’re giving him if I were doing the Mets’ books, but since when do you attract attractive players without attractive compensation? The Mets were going to have pay somebody this offseason. The four years, $66 million and whatever scheme kicks in for a potential fifth year…insane in real life, but about par for a team that will no longer be paying Delgado and Wagner their princely sums.

And how much do you suppose ticket and taco prices were going to dip next season without Jason Bay?

I’m all for tossing suggestions into the Hot Stove. But once a deal is made, unless it is so prohibitive that it makes future upgrading impossible, I’ve got to shift into Hope For The Best territory. Somebody will inevitably produce reliable data proving Jason Bay shares more than initials with the second coming of Jeromy Burnitz, that he is sheer detriment and no asset. Yet until somebody who brandishes proof that Bay is a self-inflicting wound waiting to happen is appointed to the board of Sterling Mets, it won’t matter. I’ll be willing to complain if and when Bay is a total bust, but if he’s here, he’s here with a clean slate. Jason Bay’s my leftfielder. I don’t think he’ll turn the team around by himself, but I don’t think any one player can turn this team around.

One player can help, though. Suddenly, a lineup with Bay joining Francoeur, Wright, Beltran, Reyes — if all are healthy — is better than whatever we watched most of 2009. Suddenly, three professional outfielders who aren’t undercooked or over the hill will patrol our outfield. Suddenly, the Mets might be a wee bit better in a couple of departments.

The starting pitching’s a mess. I can’t blame that on Jason Bay. The Mets need to find some arms. They need a catcher (preferably one who won’t wear 6-4-3 on his back all season). They could use an upgrade at first and second. All that’s obvious enough to blot out illusions that this is supposed to be the free agent who delivers us to the doorstep of the Promised Land. Jason Bay’s presence will be magnified for a while because he’s the new, expensive toy, but we’ll settle in with him and accept him as a part of a hopefully long-term solution, not a singular solution himself. Here’s a multipart plan: Bay and an arm or two this year; suck less as a unit; and don’t go nuts with expectations. Improve from lousy ’09 and keep an eye on next year’s market. We’re not in this for only what lies directly ahead.

I’m conditioned to think of Mets free agents first as Tom Hausman and Elliot Maddox — scrap heap bargains that even the Dollar Tree couldn’t move — and second as Bobby Bonilla ticking time bomb disasters. Occasionally, however, the Mets make a decent signing. Like Robin Ventura. Like Carlos Beltran. Like Jason Bay? Could be.

I’ve long rued learning that the strong Rookie of the Year candidate Pittsburgh was featuring in 2004 had been a Met farmhand two years earlier. I didn’t have any better idea of Jason Bay’s pre-breakthrough existence than Steve Phillips did when he traded him for Steve Reed and Jason Middlebrook. Difference is only one of us was paid to be general manager of a big league ballclub. Yeah, Bay pinged around a bit before blossoming as a Buc. Yeah, Montreal GM Omar Minaya overlooked his talents, too. So now Minaya and the Mets make amends for Phillips dismissing Bay as nothing more than a fifth outfielder, if I recall his after-the-fact appraisal. That always makes me feel good in winter, like our getting Burnitz and Roger Cedeño back once upon a time, even if the homecoming angle won’t matter at all come summer.

In the frosty interim, Bay’s backstory is a bonus. His track record’s not bad either. However he measures up to Matt Holliday is immaterial. There was no indication Holliday wanted to be in New York, and he would have required a far larger and longer commitment. Besides, Coors Field players make me nervous outside their natural habitat. Our consolation prize is a leftfielder who can hit. Is he perfect for the manufactured quirks of Citi Field? I’d maintain all we really know about Citi Field, besides its initial resistance to photos of Mookie Wilson, is that a terrible team played in it for 81 games and looked terrible doing so. Let’s see what happens with a somewhat better and less disabled crew now that it’s less altogether mysterious.

I’ll admit I’m susceptible to the allure of brand-name players whom I don’t watch every day. I thought Francoeur was a fine idea last July based on idealized glimpses of him from his better moments in Atlanta (also, Ryan Church just depressed the living spit out of me). I recall Bay pounding the Mets silly several years ago as a Pirate and noticed the Red Sox didn’t miss too many beats when he took over for Manny Ramirez. I understand there are drawbacks. That’s gonna be the case for any leftfielder who isn’t a young, not yet corrupted Barry Bonds.

We’ve just come through one of the most grismal periods in Mets history. Hell, I’m not sure we’re still not in it. Just about everything since the ninth inning of Game Seven has ranged from grim to dismal. When the Mets take a break from saddening us and embarrassing themselves to sign a player who doesn’t out and out suck — who may actually do the opposite — I think we owe it to ourselves, within reason and the realm of our understandable caution and cynicism, to enjoy it, take a little heart from it and feel a tad better about life because of it.

This decade of Mets baseball killed us over and over again. That wasn’t Jason Bay’s fault either. We desperately need a new decade. Pending a physical, however, we won’t need a new leftfielder because we’ll have one.

Welcome to the Mets, Jason Bay. And welcome, all of us, to 2010.

16 comments to The First Met of the Next Decade

  • I’m really not concerned with 2013+ right now. or next year. If Bay is a little worn down in the end and we have one (and it’d only be one right now) bad contract, the Mets can work with that.

    Bay makes this lineup formidable. We were near the top in OBP/AVG last year. 2008 we led the league in runs scored. No reason to think that we can’t do both in 2010. The lineups good enough now that we can live with no power from Castillo (and utilize his powerful OBP with Bay, Beltran and hopefully Wright blasting him in) We can let Murphy grow and improve like many of this he will. There will be games when Murphy looks bad, Francoeur swings at everything and misses, and Molina erases runners in front of him and the Mets lose, but unless all three happen at once, it’ll be a tough lineup.

    One pitcher. That’s all I ask. There isn’t a ton out there, so find me one pitcher that we all like better than Livan Hernandez and I think not only will the Mets compete, they’ll compete hard. Our lineup already matches up, and I think our rotation would too.

    The other thing, new player, clean slate please. Forgive and forget any rumors, any hard negotiations, anything that’s been done previously. He’s a Met in 2010, and I’m going to great him with hope and optimism. not anger and dismay.

  • My mind keeps going back to my trip to PNC in 2007 where Pirates fans–PIRATES FANS–were begging for Bay to be traded.

    But hey, as my brick outside our stupid home says, “forever hoping”.

    • In the Pirates fans’ defense, 2007 was clearly Bay’s worst year. In Bay’s defense, if you visited Citi Field (or Shea before it) from out of town, you might go home and tell your friends, “I thought they had such good players, but I actually heard Mets fans saying they’ve gotta trade Beltran and Reyes.” Nobody looks that great in your team’s uniform.

    • Astromets

      In Bay’s defense, this is the same group of fans that bought tickets so they could get up en masse and walk out of the middle of a game to make a point to ownership a few seasons ago. They obviously aren’t that smart if they want to trade their one asset when his value was lowest.

  • Joe D.

    Hi Greg,

    As I mentioned to Jason (Fry, not Bay) yesterday, Citifield will do to Jason (Bay, not Fry) what it already has done to Wright, Beltran and Francoeur. The strong lineup will be handicapped by airport-type dimensions.

    Hope I am wrong.

  • […] Prince of Faith and Fear in Flushing is happy to have Bay, but says, “Mind you, I’m not overwhelmed by his presence.  […]

  • […] Prince of Faith and Fear in Flushing is happy to have Bay, but says, “Mind you, I’m not overwhelmed by his presence.  He’s not a […]

  • Big Al

    Jason Bay should do okay, but he’s getting paid an awful lot of money just to be okay.

    Hey, Greg Prince, don’t you think the Mets should cut the black out of their uniforms and revert to their classic orange and blue? That would be kind of neat. . .

    • I don’t hate the black in that “it’s an affront” sense so many Mets fans claim, but if it disappeared tomorrow, I wouldn’t kick…assuming it wasn’t replaced with paisley.

      I do, however, hate the drop shadow.

  • SJGMoney

    Can I get an Amen!!!!!

  • Dan

    Bay immediately has a 50/50 shot at being the best hitting LF we’ve ever had. I outline that more at

    Given new-found love of defense, the fact that we’re spending a lot of money, and that it’s going to a guy who will be 35 and battered by the time the deal ends, I understand (and agree with) the criticism of the deal. But it’s not a bad deal, just one with downside. And we could be getting our best offensive LF *ever*, and LF isn’t like SS where offense isn’t (basically) everything. It kinda is.

    • I hope you’re right, but I also hesitate to project too high or far. If we were having this conversation in February 1982, we’d all agree that we just acquired the surefire best-hitting left fielder in Mets history. Instead, somebody switched the real George Foster in transit and we got a department store mannequin.

  • NostraDennis

    “Grismal”. Add that to your Mets dictionary.

  • Jason Bay 5 for 18 with 2 home runs the last two years against Roy Halladay. It’s not like they signed him for that, but it’s nice when you are dishing out $65 million in the hopes of getting back to the playoffs.

  • […] he’s been called back. An expensive call, but one for which we’ve accepted the charges. Come April 5, Jason Bay’s destiny […]