The blog for Mets fans
who like to read


Greg Prince and Jason Fry
Faith and Fear in Flushing made its debut on Feb. 16, 2005, the brainchild of two longtime friends and lifelong Met fans.

Greg Prince discovered the Mets when he was 6, during the magical summer of 1969. He is a Long Island-based writer, editor and communications consultant. Contact him here.

Jason Fry is a Brooklyn writer whose first memories include his mom leaping up and down cheering for Rusty Staub. Check out his other writing here.

Got something to say? Leave a comment, or email us at (Sorry, but we have no interest in ads, sponsored content or guest posts.)

Need our RSS feed? It's here.

Visit our Facebook page, or drop by the personal pages for Greg and Jason.

Or follow us on Twitter: Here's Greg, and here's Jason.

No Pony In Sight

There’s an old joke about an inveterate optimist and a pile of horse manure, the punch line of which is, “There’s gotta be a pony in there somewhere.” And indeed, you’d think that after the last 18 innings of steaming, redolent folderol in Atlanta, the least the Mets would be able to pull out of the heap is one shiny win.

But no. Nothing shiny, nothing winning, nothing doing. Nothing much good from two games filled with gobs of movement, but little in the way of positive action.

You’d think 12 runs and 24 hits delivered across two games, much of it manufactured in classic resilient Met fashion, would have resulted in some semblance of triumph for your gritty, gutty visitors from the north. Turner Field, as it tends to do more often than not, has had other ideas. A 7-5 Mets loss Friday. An 8-7 loss Saturday. In neither case did the Mets look good, yet in both cases the Mets seemed perched on the precipice of looking fine. A couple of hits that never came Friday spelled the big difference between holding a lead and trying to make up a deficit against Craig Kimbrel. But the hits, as noted, never came.

Saturday, there were hits, there was a lead late and for all the umpire-instigated nonsense swirling about them, there was every reason to believe the Mets were going to emerge from their mess clean for day. But here came the Met bullpen again, this time more deadly than the last. When Messrs. Byrdak, Beato and Parnell were through in the bottom of the eighth, a lead became another deficit and Atlanta’s talented Mr. Kimbrel was on the scene once more, even more invincible than usual.

And there goes the old ballgame again. Two in a row in Atlanta, three in a row overall if you can remember back to last Sunday when the Mets decided to get an early start on their break.

What a mess.

The phrase, “R.A. Dickey didn’t have it,” is becoming unpleasantly common to inject into these recountings, but R.A. Dickey didn’t have it. Nor did Jordany Valdespin, though Dale Scott said he did. Dale Scott was the umpire who ruled there was a catch on a trap in the bottom of the fifth with one out. Valdespin acted the part of the successful left fielder, held a ball Jason Heyward hit aloft and followed through with what seemed to be some kind of slow-moving 7-4-3 DP on Martin Prado. But replay — the same mechanism that proved C.B. Bucknor had earlier blown a safe call on Valdespin at first — showed Scott was dead wrong and (unfortunately for us) the two umpires who weren’t that idiot Bucknor convinced Scott that the catch was a trap.

From there, the double play Dickey thought had gotten him out of the fifth was revoked. Thus, he had to stick around and continue pitching the fifth, and two batters later, Freddie Freeman unloaded a double to score Prado and Heyward and give the Braves a 5-3 lead. Worst part was the Braves redeemed an opportunity they deserved to have. Terry Collins had argued it to the point of ejection, but he was wrong (though not wrong to argue — it’s what managers are supposed to do). Fox was no immediate help in explaining why he was wrong, but why expect anything remotely insightful from baseball’s broadcast network of record? They’ve only held the MLB rights for 17 seasons.

I suppose Fox is proof of the adage that fans don’t tune in for the broadcast but for the game, and that Fox is double proof that fans don’t tune out the game because of the broadcast, but geez, they’re awful. How is it there are nearly 312 million people in this great country of ours, and the best Fox can come up with for a game of the week are the disengaged Chris Myers and the clueless Eric Karros?

Anyway, Dickey wasn’t good, Myers and Karros were abominable, the Mets were one slice shy of a loaf every time you turned around, yet there they were, lifting our sights the way they are capable of elevating them, pushing three runs across in the sixth and another in the eighth after the reversal-of-fortune call, so you can’t say (no matter how those numbskulls in the booth framed it) the Mets were doomed by the trap. They instead set their own trap later when Geren/Collins trusted the bullpen to hold a two-run lead with two innings to go.

Couldn’t be done. First Byrdak issued a walk to Brian McCann, who’s no Ned in the third reader but exactly the kind of batter (lefthanded) hilarious Hulk is supposed to retire. Out goes Tim, in comes Pedro, and he gave up one horribly long single to Dan Uggla (how was he not a Brave all those years?) before striking out the kid Pastornicky. Another hitting-pitching change had Bobby Parnell striking out Juan Francisco, but then…well, it was like the Braves knew what was coming. They probably did know what was coming, as it was unimpressive fastball after unimpressive fastball that Michael Bourn, then Prado and then Heyward whacked effectively enough to produce one, make it two, no make it three runs.

Bingo. 8-7, Atlanta. Just enough cushion for Kimbrel’s unhittable arsenal to be deployed. Ike, Murph and the hobbled Duda all flailed and all fanned. Ballgame.

What kills about these two games, besides that each was there for the taking and Saturday’s screamed to be swooped up and secured, was that you’re not losing to a club of worldbeaters over there in the other dugout. The Braves looked maybe one iota better, net, across the two days, yet they get to enjoy all the fruits of victory — which matters not only because they were the opponent, but they’re a little ahead of us in this playoff race we weren’t expecting to be in. They’re now a little more ahead of us than they were before Friday and we’re a little less in the race, but we’re still there. Of course we are. Most of the National League is. Even Eric Karros could analyze the situation accurately: You have to win these head-to-head games. And since almost everybody is still kind of contending, you can’t afford to lose any games you play in pairs.

A few good signs exist from these disasters. Josh Edgin, Chipper initiation notwithstanding, seems hyperuseful. Andres Torres’s bat has woken up, or at least hasn’t given into the snooze alarm. Ruben Tejada got even better over the break. Valdespin, once he’s informed that he’s already gotten off the island, might learn to take a pitch and turn his certain something into something relentlessly positive. Ike has just about stopped sucking.

But familiar bullpen blues, failure to pile on and all-around growing pains aside, Young was terrible, Dickey wasn’t passable and Gee isn’t here. Johan’s ankle (a.k.a. The Johankle) needs to prove it isn’t a detriment Sunday and Niese isn’t entitled to be inconsistent in Washington. Beyond that, it’s either Old Timer Day next Saturday with Miguel Batista or the likely unready aces of tomorrow today. If this were a flat-out lousy season, I’d be salivating to see Harvey or, as long as they’re dropping breadcrumbs about him, Wheeler (who threw a Double-A shutout Saturday night). This is still a good season. I don’t know that I want one of our top prospects being set down on our mound amid Fire Time, as Collins calls these defining days of July. Come to think of it, has anybody seen Terry manage a legitimate playoff hunt in this century? Will there be a legitimate playoff hunt by August 1?

You can’t let two bad results pull the thread on what has been an encouraging tapestry. But spend seven-plus hours with this team over these bad and worse games and try to have faith the sun’ll come out tomorrow.

It will, probably, but I wouldn’t rush to bet my bottom dollar.

12 comments to No Pony In Sight

  • Andee

    It’s real simple. Without a bullpen, you don’t have anything. And when whoever’s in charge manages the bullpen like a monkey using color-coded index cards, it’s even worse. Parnell never should have been sent out there to get five outs with two runners already on. Not in that house of doom. He’s not ready for that yet. He’s getting better and someday he might be that guy, but he’s not there yet. Geren should have let Beato stay in there and finish the inning; if he blew chunks, at least they wouldn’t have burned through Parnell too. How on earth did they need to use three relievers in one inning to cough up three runs?

  • Andee

    As for the Horsemen, I doubt Wheeler goes to the show this year simply because he’s already at 115 innings and he’s capped at 150 this year; 35 innings can go by in less than a month. Harvey’s promotion will probably depend on how he does on Monday. If it’s not so hot, they’ll probably leave him where he is, at least until we can’t take even one more start from Poetry Man (or heaven forfend, until someone else gets hurt).

  • Dave

    While I’m watching the game, I’m looking at the clock and something’s not right…somehow Turner Field must be in this other timezone that kept returning to midnight, because I kept seeing everything turn back into pumpkins. Curse you, second halves.

  • Adam

    That broadcast was just bafflingly remedial yesterday. My favorite part was when Eric Karros explained in pedantic terms why Andres Torres had to run back to 3rd base to tag up in order to score on a pop fly. Thanks for the cutting-edge insight there, bruh.

  • Patrick O'Hern

    Karros-“Chipper Jones, who’s had some success against the Mets over the years….” Really????

  • Jacobs27

    The one breath of fresh air in the broadcast was Phil Niekro, who, I think, hit the nail on the head about what’s troubling with Dickey lately.

    He’s throwing an awful lot of knuckleballs at about the same speed in about the same place, up in the strike zone. That sort of hard “rising” knuckler was a great innovation, but I feel he’s been relying on it a bit too much, and not always executing overall. I’d like to see him change it up a lot more.

    • Niekro alone would have been a treat without those dopes, though aren’t guest spots what pregame shows are for?

      • Jacobs27

        I kinda felt that way a little while ago when Seaver and Kiner were in the booth at the same time on SNY. It should have been a great moment, but instead they were just kind of talking over each other, confusingly, and not about the game.
        The Mets were in the middle of coughing up a lead or something. It was really too bad.

  • Joe D.

    The problem with our bullpen can be summed up in three words: Krod, Takahashi and Issringhausen. Ok, need to add a fourth to that: ex-Mets.

    But hey, in terms of money ball I bet we’re doing really good.

  • Tom

    Anyone have trouble with the 5-out save Bob Geren asked Parnell to walk into? He’s still learning how to deal with one inning. I know they’re shy a closer, but Rauch and Beato were pulled a little early, I think. Even if you take into consideration their own troubles. It just seemed like a lot for somebody like Parnell to handle.

  • Will in Central NJ

    I’ve written it before, I’ll write it again: Bobby Parnell is another Juan Acevedo. When they throw the ball, you hear ‘kapow’. Sometimes, it’s the sound of the ball in the catcher’s mitt. Other times, it’s the sound of the bat meeting the ball. Plus, both wear/wore #39. Sigh…