The blog for Mets fans
who like to read


Greg Prince and Jason Fry
Faith and Fear in Flushing made its debut on Feb. 16, 2005, the brainchild of two longtime friends and lifelong Met fans.

Greg Prince discovered the Mets when he was 6, during the magical summer of 1969. He is a Long Island-based writer, editor and communications consultant. Contact him here.

Jason Fry is a Brooklyn writer whose first memories include his mom leaping up and down cheering for Rusty Staub. Check out his other writing here.

Got something to say? Leave a comment, or email us at (Sorry, but we have no interest in ads, sponsored content or guest posts.)

Need our RSS feed? It's here.

Visit our Facebook page, or drop by the personal pages for Greg and Jason.

Or follow us on Twitter: Here's Greg, and here's Jason.

A Day of Halves

You know what? I’ve come around on the idea of the Mets playing the Pirates again right after the All-Star Break.

Not because I think the Pirates are a bunch of tomato cans — that’s a dangerous thing to think about any opponent, and if the Bucs win Sunday they’ll have split the series — but because all of a sudden I’m tired, and baseball’s mid-season break seems well-timed. Let Taijuan Walker justifiably beam with happiness at going to the All-Star Game and Pete Alonso hit some dingers in the Home Run Derby while the other Mets rest and the missing Mets heal and/or rehab some more and everyone enjoys some Ohtani-mania, and then we’ll pick up right where we left off with these same two teams. Though hopefully with fewer doubleheaders.

The first game of the Mets’ 10th (!!!!) doubleheader of 2021 started off well enough for the Mets, with Brandon Nimmo making like Ender Inciarte and going above the outfield fence to take a home run away from Bryan Reynolds, a play he never would have made before the Mets convinced him to play more deeply. Nimmo was at it again in the bottom of the first, swatting a leadoff single and coming home on Kevin Pillar‘s RBI hit, and with Marcus Stroman holding the Pirates hitless into the fourth it looked like the Mets were preparing for another romp: throttle the enemy with pitching and defense and ambush them late in the game.

But both the pitching and defense faltered, with John Nogowski slapping a ball down the left-field line that just eluded Jonathan Villar‘s dive and got past Dom Smith in the corner. The Mets’ defense is so greatly improved that it’s now faintly startling to see such plays not made, but that one wasn’t, and it put the Pirates up 2-1. Villar tied it with a home run, but opposing pitcher Tyler Anderson got his Camarena on in the fifth, homering off Stroman for the lead, Trevor May had a clunker of an outing that culminated in a Reynolds home run that Nimmo could only watch, and it was goodnight sweet Mets.

Hey, sometimes the other guys just play better, y’know?

The nightcap began for me on Gameday while we were out with friends, with the radio feed keeping me company via a single earbud after dinner concluded. I saw Jeff McNeil‘s IN PLAY, RUN(S), though I noted little of Tylor Megill‘s latest pretty good start — when you’re one-eyeing Gameday, solid pitching for the good guys means not being particularly aware of anything happening. It was hours before I read Megill had tied the Mets’ mark by fanning 26 in his first four starts, equaling Dick Selma, Dwight Gooden and Matt Harvey. While I think that says more about baseball’s current era of windmilling bats than anything else, it’s not bad company for a guy who was Plan D or E or F on the starting-pitching depth chart not so long ago.

I had my earbud in to hear Pete Alonso slam a ball off the foul pole, a blow that made an impressive crack in my left ear and sent Howie and Wayne into paroxysms of delight. I heard Seth Lugo surrendering a homer that let the Bucs draw closer, then Billy McKinney supplying an insurance run, and then “Timmy Trumpet” blaring as Edwin Diaz arrived for the latest episode of I Know the Stats But Our Closer Still Makes Me Nervous.

Baseball, of course, is an ever-renewing lesson that no one knows anything: Diaz put the Pirates down with almost contemptuous ease, fanning the side on a mere 10 pitches in what had to be his most dominating inning as a Met. There’s a superlative he’s welcome to challenge as many times as he likes.

* * *

The Mets have played a strange season so far, to say the very least: There’s the overhauled defense, the Biblical plague of injuries, the mysteriously MIA hitters, the contributions from unlikely sources, deGrom’s unbelievable run, the rain the rain oh lord the rain, and the thoroughly welcome disappearing act so far by the rest of the supposedly robust NL East. (Not welcome at all, though: word that Ronald Acuna Jr. tore his ACL Saturday night and may be out until late spring 2022 — no matter what the standings or who plays in your division, baseball losing one of its brightest young stars is something to mourn.)

I don’t know how this year will end, but the 2021 Mets have two little-remarked franchise marks in their sights: Nick Tropeano‘s underwhelming debut Friday night made him the 51st player to appear in a game this season. Of those 51, 31 are new to the Mets, and seven have made their MLB debuts. The Mets’ record for players appearing in a season is 56 in 2018, their record for newcomers (not counting ’62 for obvious reasons) is 35 in 1967, and their record for MLB debuts is 16 in 1995. That third mark appears safe, but the first two are very much in danger, as the ever-expanding Holy Books can attest.

8 comments to A Day of Halves

  • Harvey Poris

    Megill’s tying the first 4 starts Mets strikeout record is incorrect. In Nolan Ryan’s first 4 starts (1 in 1966 and 3 in 1968) he struck out 29 in 19.1 innings.

  • Eric

    10 doubleheaders equal 40 lost innings of Mets baseball, not counting ghost-runner extra innings.

    I’m not looking forward to the all-star break. I miss the games when there’s an off day or a rainout, and there’s been too many of those.

    I think deGrom, Stroman, and Walker in particular can use the break, though. They’ve all slipped over their last 4 or so turns.

    I feel bad for Acuna. ACL tears aren’t a common baseball injury, so I wonder how they affect baseball players. He’s young, though, which should help him recover.

    The Nationals have dropped back since the Schwarber injury, though they’ve played good teams, too. The Braves, Phillies, and Nationals have all reached .500 or a little above and then promptly stumbled back under. Even so, the Mets are still only a bad week away from losing their lead to any of the three. Maybe one of them will pull off a Cespedes-level trade and add other upgrades to make a run.

    With the Mets scrounging for starting pitching, I wonder how Flexen got so good with the Mariners.

    • Seth

      I agree. It’s been hard enough to get in a groove this year, with fits and starts, rain and snow. We don’t need 4 days off, we need to get the rhythm going.

  • Harvey Poris

    Eric-Not only Flexen. Paul Sewald, who couldn’t get out of his own way as a Met- is 5-2 with 2 saves and 1.40 ERA in 25.2 innings for the Mariners with 44 strikeouts. Seattle must have some great pitching coaches to turn Flexen and Sewald around.

  • open the gates

    It’s taken a while, but I do trust Edwin Diaz. More than any other position in baseball, being a closer has as much to do with mindset as mechanics. You have to go in there with a killer instinct, knowing you’re going to beat the other guy. Diaz had that the year before he got here, then somehow lost it in 2019. Most closers who lose it never get it back – look at Jeuris Familia, who’s also turned it around, but I still don’t know that I’d trust him as a closer anymore. Diaz somehow managed to get his killer instinct back, and for that he earns my trust. For now.

  • open the gates

    Re Flexen and Sewald – I wonder how they would have turned out if Jeremy Hefner had gotten his hands on them. Hefner’s done miracles this year, with Taijuan Walker as Exhibit A. The Mets pitching coach back then was Dave Eiland, who was supposed to be a huge deal when the Mets nabbed him, but in retrospect I think he was way overrated.

  • Eric

    Speaking of Matt Harvey, the Boone decision to let Cole finish the game last night against the Astros reminded me of Collins’s decision to let Harvey go back out in game 5.