The blog for Mets fans
who like to read

ABOUT US

Greg Prince and Jason Fry
Faith and Fear in Flushing made its debut on Feb. 16, 2005, the brainchild of two longtime friends and lifelong Met fans.

Greg Prince discovered the Mets when he was 6, during the magical summer of 1969. He is a Long Island-based writer, editor and communications consultant. Contact him here.

Jason Fry is a Brooklyn writer whose first memories include his mom leaping up and down cheering for Rusty Staub. Check out his other writing here.

Got something to say? Leave a comment, or email us at faithandfear@gmail.com. (Sorry, but we have no interest in ads, sponsored content or guest posts.)

Need our RSS feed? It's here.

Visit our Facebook page, or drop by the personal pages for Greg and Jason.

Or follow us on Twitter: Here's Greg, and here's Jason.

Welcome Back to Garbage Time

Freddy Peralta, Huascar Brazoban and Brooks Raley have followed A.J Minter to greener pastures, with the likes of Luke Weaver and Tyrone Taylor still wondering if they will have new employers come Tuesday when the Mets and Guardians renew their (checks notes) utterly nonexistent rivalry.

I’ll spare you highly amateur scouting: I know no more than you do about Émilien Pitre, John Spikerman, Luke Gabrysh or the other newcomers to the system, beyond observing that the Mets are at least restocking their roster of interestingly monikered prospects. We’ll know them better in time, or forget all about them, or most likely it will be a mix of the two.

And I don’t particularly care, to be honest — I would have happily shed Peralta for a bag of street-fair tube socks*, and while I applauded our two former relievers’ work for the Mets, in a lost season most any return would have been fine for a free agent to be and a 36-year-old reliever at the likely peak of his value. Weaver’s fate remains the most intriguing trade-deadline question; given relievers’ innate unpredictability season to season, I’m not opposed to seeing him move, but it better be for a genuinely decent return.

The Mets at least took some of the sting out of this trade deadline by showing us by May that we could make other October plans, turning Departure Day into a when, not an if. But I’m still flashing back to the 2023 selloff, the last time the Mets hosed out the stables.

There’s a certain relief to definitively and authoritatively turning the page, but that doesn’t last: Pretty soon it dawns on you that the next seven weeks will be spent watching a jackass-carpentry roster, many of whose pieces will be discarded as square pegs by the time spring training rolls around. Remember Adam Kolarek, Jonathan Arauz or Sam Coonrod? Me neither.**

That won’t be fun, to say the least. On the other hand, the bleak trudge of Garbage Time 2023 was followed a year later by a wonderfully unexpected spring revival and a march nearly all the way to the World Series. The Mets will likely look very different come 2027,*** but they’ll probably have a corps of intriguing young starters and a not bad (at least on paper) offensive nucleus. You can dream on less, and goodness if you’re a Mets fan you already have.

* * *

Sunday’s actual game is best dispensed with quickly, as the Mets reminded us why this year has been so hopeless by getting zilch from a bases-loaded, no-out situation when they were poised to tie the Marlins or even take the lead.

The one exception was the unexpected sight of Robert Stock, whom Emily and I just saw on the mound up in Syracuse, and who made two starts for the Mets back in 2021.

Stock is an interesting guy with an intriguing bio, having plugged away in indy ball and overseas among stints with eight different MLB organizations; he was impressive this spring before being felled by thoracic outlet syndrome. He’s an engineer’s kid who’d built websites as a teenager, so last offseason he used Claude to create Stockyard Baseball, an open-source pitch model. (Meanwhile, I was drinking bourbon and buying shit I didn’t need.)

Stock made all of one bad pitch Sunday; he’ll turn 37 shortly after the World Series, so don’t expect him to be part of the long- or even medium-term answer. But he’s someone to root for before the curtain falls, and we’ll need all of that we can get.

* We’ll undoubtedly face him in Tampa Bay and I’m sure he’ll hit us with seven scoreless innings. I am already bitter.

** The only player to emerge from 2023’s Garbage Time scrum? Reed Garrett.

*** Let’s not discuss the looming labor war. It’s too depressing right now.

9 comments to Welcome Back to Garbage Time

  • Seth

    If the team is giving up on the season, maybe the fans should too?

  • Curt Emanuel

    What I really want is to trade our infield. It has to be the worst hitting one in baseball and since they aren’t much defensively I’d nominate them for worst in baseball, not that I’m familiar with every other team.

    With Raley and Brazoban gone I’m hoping this means we hang onto Weaver. Can’t completely ditch our relievers if we want to do something next year and I’ve never been in favor of trading either of our catchers. I’m on the fence about Holmes. I am hoping we have a Nate Lavender sighting before long.

  • Left Coast Jerry

    There’s a rule in high school baseball that a team must start a game with 9 players, but they can finish with 8 if they don’t have a replacement for an injured player. Every time the missing player’s spot in the lineup comes up, the offense is charged an out. This is what I see every time Jorge Polanco takes a turn at bat.

  • eric1973

    Really dumb they traded Weaver. Guess the Spreadsheet King figured since Weaver had a good season this year that he will have a bad one next year.

    I think his computer spit out the results as 50.1% to 49.9%.

    Now they need a Weaver-type for 2027, but, alas, we already had one.

    • Not too chuffed about trading Weaver.

      He brought back a real chip, and while you’re right that they need a Weaver-type for 2027, given relievers’ maddening year-to-year swings there’s no guarantee Weaver would have been, well, that Weaver-type.

      Last year when he was tipping pitches and getting shellacked we would have driven him to the airport ourselves. He did great work for us and was a fun clubhouse interview, so I’ll miss him for that, but not upset about the move.

  • Rumble

    Holmes and Taylor to
    The Cubs for an infield prospect Baseball
    America ranked as the 99th prospect

    Stearns is a schmuck . . . and Cohen is in love with him